You neither satisfactorily addressed my questions nor refrained from your usual uncivil manner in addressing me. My questions speak to the future of the program while you elect to recite the past. Unresponsive, ungentlemanly, and unsatisfactory.
I can see some of the points you are both making. Here's my lengthy take. On the one hand, yes Dawn has proven to be one of the best coaches in the country and has obviously brought USC to national prominence with 4 (not 5) regular season SEC titles, 4 SEC Tourney titles, 2 Final Fours, a national title etc. That puts USC in the same company IMO with about 10 or so schools nationally in terms of reputation, even if the resume is not the same (UCONN, Baylor, Notre Dame and add other top 15 teams such as Louisville, Texas, Maryland, A&M, Ohio State and other rising teams Miss State and Oregon to name a few.) Even without having won the last 2 titles UCONN is still the biggest team to beat in the recruiting wars evidenced by USC losing out to UCONN for 2 big time forwards in the last year.
With the success, there is nothing wrong with expressing "concern" since we all want the team to be a final four team every year, but it's not so easy to do even when you have a ton of talent (as the 2016 team clearly illustrated after being upset in Sweet 16).
2 points:
1) Even when you do get the players you think you want, the ratings system can be a crap shoot. Araion Bradshaw was 5-start that didn't pan out and she left after one year. According to ESPN, our recent recruiting classes were #10 last year (with Lele and company), #11 the year before, unranked the year before that because we signed only 1 freshman, and #2 the year USC signed A'ja. The frustrating part of it all, and this is no unique to USC by any means, is the large rate of attrition and "misses." Look at the previous 4 classes: (not each kid has different reasons for leaving, just pointing out facts and you can make your own conclusions)
4 years ago: A'ja Wilson, Jatarie White, Bianca Cuevas, Doniyah Cliney, Kaydra Duckett.
3 of the 5 did not finish their eligibility at USC. Aja was great. Bianca did good things and opted to finish her career elsewhere, and Cliney has been serviceable as a starter. Duckett and White both left.
3 years ago: Shay Colley was the only signee and left midway through season. USC had transfers Davis and Gray waiting in the wings, but did not count as part of the recruiting class. USC was certainly fortunate that they decided to leave UNC and Ga. Tech!
2 years ago: Bradshaw, Victoria Patrick, Ty Harris, Kiki Harrigan. Bradshaw left after 1 year. Patrick left this year. Ty has been great, and Kiki has been good and has potential to be very good, and we shall see how she adjusts to being an every day starter where more is demanded of her.
1 year ago: LaDazia Williams, Lele Grissett, Bianca Jackson, Haley Troup. Troup left before the season started. Jackson had a nice freshman year. You can see the athleticism in the other 2 but not a whole lot of results yet. So the jury is out on those 2.
So in the previous 4 years, USC signed 14 freshmen. 6 transferred before their eligibility was over. Some great signees, some that didn't work out. To me, that puts us in the same boat as just about every other top 15 team in the country.
2) I've heard this said before, and I agree with it 100%. The biggest issue has been the lack of outstanding IN-STATE talent coming out of high school the last 4 years. I'm guessing that most 18 year old girls like to play close to home, so getting out of state studs is quite a coup. USC built its program with the likes of Welch (SC kid), Mitchell (Charlotte), Sessions (SC kid), Dozier (SC kid), Coates (SC kid), and Wilson (SC kid). To my knowledge there has not been a high school stud coming out of the state of South Carolina since A'ja's class, and that hurts.