With the Doty situation. I got a question for yall
- Thread starter jeff2001
- Start date
You always go with the quarterback that gives you the best chance to win, and that's something the coaches will obviously have to determine in practice. I do believe it would be wise, however, to give your backup some meaningful snaps.
Absolutely not. Why would you ever replace what’s working with an unknown? You slowly ease him back into games after it’s been decided to shake the rust off and give him the chance to win the job back.
This is impossible to answer definitively. A lot of variables here. Blowing up vs Eastern Illinois doesn't equal blowing up vs Georgia.
How good do you think we are? We won two games last year. We won four games the year before. I know very little about ECU's roster, but it isn't hard to believe East Carolina has a better Qb.
It could also be that Doty picked up the offense quicker and is quicker on the reads than the other QBs, in other words he’s the better qb.
I'd be stunned if Doty is out there for the EIU game. That's a little over 2 weeks away and it's highly unlikely he'd be back to full strength until sometime next week, at the earliest. That's just a lot of critical practice time to be missing. The caveat would be if he's far ahead of the other QBs, which may be the case. IF he's the starter for EIU, that'll tell us the coaches view him as being head and shoulders above the other guys.
Not Only a Better QB,, but not a single guy on SC roster is as good as their QB.. LAUGHABLE!!!
I will say this, watching and listening to Colten Gauthier is encouraging. We could have something special here, way too early to say but I like his energy and composure.
I'd stay with the backup as long as he's performing at a high level...at the first sign that his play is slipping, however, I'd bring in a replacement.
It's not uncommon for an unproven player to have a handful of very good games, only to come back to earth once other teams are aware of tendencies and weaknesses. Certainly, there are situations when the opposite is true - Brady and Gerhig mentioned as prominent examples already.
Each situation is unique...it's ultimately up to the coach to chart the best path forward given the uniqueness of these situations when they arise.
It's not uncommon for an unproven player to have a handful of very good games, only to come back to earth once other teams are aware of tendencies and weaknesses. Certainly, there are situations when the opposite is true - Brady and Gerhig mentioned as prominent examples already.
Each situation is unique...it's ultimately up to the coach to chart the best path forward given the uniqueness of these situations when they arise.
I didn't make the post, I only agreed with it. Maybe slightly exaggerated. Who are the playmakers on our team?
NONE apparently, I am being told, with which i disagreed, that their QB is "TWICE as Good as anyone on SC team?. Twice as good?? lifts twice as much?? Twice as fast?? Twice as Smart?? etc etc etc Not sure how he could possibly even measure that if it was not such a preposterous claim...
Kevin Harris, Says Hi!! Enagbare says hi, Joyner says hi, just to name a couple, so in my opinion i wouldnt trade any of these three for "THEIR" QB.. Much less 1/2 of their QB!!
Is Harris healthy and ready to go?
Joyner is a playmaker?
Enagbare, glad he decided to return.
I think your anger is misplaced.
I do believe this question was ask to satterfield in the press conference go to 16:10 in the video.
He’s still an unknown to the coaches as well. He may look like amazing in practice but there is nothing to support that in an actual game he’ll be successful. He’s 0-3 as a starter with more INTs than TDs.
Didnt realize that their QB was twice as good as all above..... I apologize NM
Jason Brown is the most accurate of all QBs, has the quickest release of all and has that it factor , he is a playmaker, he takes the top off of defenses by that I mean he has that vision down field that either you have it or you don't he does . Here's what is holding him back. He has been in a spread no huddle offense all his life and now the coaches are asking him to huddle that's been his problem. But make no mistake he is a playmaker at QB
nope, has to win it back in practice. Isn't that what led to Muschamp having to leave UF?
Interesting question. But blowing up against the first two opponents would be the wrong measuring stick IMO. Maybe Doty gets the job back but is on a very short leash. After all you have one or two games to evaluate with Brown or Gauthier, perhaps.
Just another data point to enter into the QB competition which should run all year.
No coach Sat nothing is promised and when Luke comes back they will evaluate the state of the team and position at that point and time
In our situation Doty is QB1 once he returns. He earned his spot in camp but never got his shot. Now if say midseason Doty goes down during a game and we just look like a better team without him we can discuss handing the keys over.
