In 2012, we endured the double whammy of losing the greatest college baseball coach in the country, and hiring a rookie AD. Not a good week for the University.
The thinking was at the time that Tanner had earned this opportunity. He had just taken our baseball program to three straight CWS championship series, winning two of them. He wanted to transition from coaching to administration, and he had generated such good will among fans, our president and the BOT, that in the immediate aftermath of that CWS success, and with the endorsement of outgoing AD Hyman, we handed the keys over to Tanner.
I do think its important to point out that Tanner has done some things well. He has unified this athletic department in a palpable way. There seems to be genuine good will and harmony in the department - something that has often been far from the case at USC. Coaches respect him because he is one of them, and he is a legend in coaching ranks.
However, his hires have been poor. Our most successful coach (Staley) was a Hyman hire. Martin was a Hyman hire. Shelley Smith (W. soccer) was a McGee hire. Beverly Smith (softball) was a Hyman hire. Tanner's hires have been his good friend Holbrook (fired), Muschamp (hot seat), and Kingston (verdict is still out, but looking tenuous).
He has been learning on the job for eight years now, and its impossible to argue that the department is better off now than it was in 2012, aside from finances, which are thriving thanks to big SEC payouts. Certainly for football and baseball, the success of 2010-2012 seems a distant memory. Men's basketball, in all fairness, and regardless of your feelings toward Martin, is in much better shape than it was in 2012.
Tanner is a great guy. A Gamecock legend. We need to never forget that, and must tread carefully with this. I agree that a change is needed, but it has to be done the right way. We need a proven, seasoned AD, in the mold of Hyman, who can steady the ship, and simultaneously manage to maintain harmony within the department. Let's see if our new president can navigate those perilous waters.