It's exactly like that.
When minorities are overrepresented, nobody questions it. "That's just the way it worked out" is an acceptable answer. When minorities are underrepresented, that is absolutely not an acceptable answer.
Race shouldn't even be in the discussion. The cream always rises to the top. But that's not the world we live in.
We have evidence that black quarterbacks weren't given chances that they deserved.
Black players that had been quarterbacks in high school and college were all of a sudden moved to defensive back positions or wide outs- positions that some had never played (and didn't want to play).
That's what happened to the first black QB in the modern area- Marlin Briscoe. When he got to Denver, they took the college QB Brisco and tried to move him to DB. He refused to sign unless they gave him a chance to play QB in their 3 day try-out for QB.
Seven other quarterbacks, all of them white, got to make 10 throws during drills. Briscoe always went last, and got “maybe seven or eight”.
At the end of camp, Denver named Briscoe a starter – at cornerback. But after starting quarterback Steve Tensi was injured and backup Joe DiVito struggled during the Broncos’ home opener, coach Lou Saban put Briscoe in under center.
Briscoe completed his first pass for 22 yards. He later drove Denver 80 yards, scored on a 12-yard run, and nearly led the Broncos to a comeback win. A week later, he became the first black starting quarterback in pro football’s modern era – and ultimately finished the season as the runner-up for AFL rookie of the year, compiling five starts, 1,589 passing yards, 308 rushing yards and 14 touchdown passes.
The following summer, Briscoe went back to Omaha to take college courses. His phone rang. “Denver was having quarterback meetings,” he said. “Here I am, the starting QB at the end of the season, and I didn’t even get an invitation to the competition.”
Briscoe flew to Denver. He discovered his services under center were no longer needed. “I never did get an explanation,” he said. “But I understood what was going on.”