It used to be appointment TV. But like a lot of things these days - the internet made it irrelevant. Why watch a whole show when you can have up to the minute highlights at the palm of your hand?
I also think the shtick got kind of old. Watching Berman do his highlights now is more sad than anything. He made a whole career on silly nicknames and three stooges sounds - and when he does that now you wonder how that was ever entertaining to begin with. It was at the time for sure, but highlights with cheeky announcers is lame now.