I am pretty sure I would be pissing my pants if I had to return a punt!
In 9th grade I was on Jv team and was not extremely fast but shifty. Coach put me back to return kick off against the Varsity team and I returned it for a TD. Returned another for 30 or so Yds.
Then, they put me on punt return. Some how the ball just slipped through my hands and some dude tried his best to drive his helmet through my torso as the ball fell to the ground. Thank God that was last time I was asked to return a punt lol.
Takes a huge Pair to return those punts in college. I think the great ones are a little crazy.