Sorry ReelEss, but I just now came across your inquiry!
Again I HIGHLY recommend The Mill Pond, especially for a special get-together!!!
As far as what I suggest or prefer, man ALL THEIR STUFF IS FANTASTIC!! Their steak options are all wonderful, and in all honesty, I can only suggest is that you simply decide for yourself!! I am very certain you will not regret your visit there, nor your own choice of grub!!
Also, and simply as a side note, the following photo from their website is WOAD, the LARGEST GATOR in SC IMHO!!! Certainly within the top 5 by a long shot!! Odds are pretty good that you'll be able to see this thing if your visit occurs during our summer months, while enjoying either a pre or post sit down meal drink right out on their back deck than spans the lake there!!!