2017 with Coates: (5) Coates (4) Wilson (3) Gray (2)Davis (1) Fr. Harris
2017 without Coates: (5)Wilson (4)Gray (3) Davis (2) Cuevas (1) Fr. Harris
2020 (5) Boston (4)Harrigan (3)Beal (2) Cooke (1) Sr. Harris
With Coates: 2017 team is better at the 4 and 3. It is a tossup at the 2 because Davis was a matchup problem although she was not consistent. 2020 is better at the 5 and 1. Boston is more versatile that Coates and of course senior Ty is better.
Without Coates: 2017 team is better at the 5,4, and 3. A'ja is better than Boston at this stage in her career, Cooke is better than Cuevas, and again senior Ty is better than Freshman Ty.
The thing that makes 2020 better is not the starting 5 but the bench.
Yep, at this point, the foursome of Wilson, Coates, Davis, and Gray are better than our top 4 of Boston, Cooke, Herbert-Harrigan, and Harris. But only slightly.
The difference is, once you get past those 4 from 2017, the offensive contributions drop off substantially than what the rest of the 2020 team is providing. This season's team does not have as big of holes in the overall team dynamic, as many of those A'ja Wilson teams had. For the most part, those teams had holes in the starting unit offensively. Asia Dozier was a very heady overall player, but she did not really bring a lot to the table offensively or defensively.
Khadijah Sessions was a good ball manager in transition offense - she was never that great at ball distribution, especially in getting the ball into our bigs Coates, Ibiam, or Wilson for much of her career: both Tiffany Mitchell and Dozier were better ball passers than Sessions ever was. And while Sessions would ultimately become a very reliable on-man defensive player at the end of her career, where she was being given the assignments against the top offensive guards for opponents - and did well in the job - she was never even a solid offensive contributor to the team.
Both Dozier and Sessions were primary starters after their freshman seasons. They were all we had - after the years of Sutton, Grant, and Walker leading the SEC and in the top 5 nationally in perimeter and scoring defense, it was a tough job to follow up on. But in 2013-14 we went 29-5, and those 5 losses were to our 4 toughest opponents (UNC twice). They deployed a simple, common defense:
That season we had 4 players for 3 positions: Mitchell, Aleighsa Welch, and Elem Ibiam and Alaina Coates playing the 5. Out of that group, Tiffany was the only dependable perimeter shooter - she still owns the SEC all-time single-season record for 3-pt FG %. We know where Ibiam and Coates would get their points, and Welch may have had a little 10-15 ft. jumper, but she was more of a fast, athletic dribble-driver to the basket for layups. So the opponents would face-guard Mitchell, and make it very hard for the Gamecocks to get her the ball, then the rest of the team would crash down hard on the paint, and blanket whoever of the bigs were in there.
This put pressure on Welch, who already had to go into that blanket defense waiting for her to get most of her pts, or become a preimeter jump-shooter, which she was not. Or, it forced either Dozier or Sessions, or whoever came in off of the bench, to hit perimeter shots to break up that defense and pull it back out.
Those 5 losses, Dozier and Sessions shot less than 24% and averaged around 3 ppg. We just had huge holes.
Then when Davis and Gray joined WIlson and Coates, our starting 5 carried the team the whole way to the title. The bench produced very little that year - Bianca Cuevas-Moore struggled earlier in the season and lost her starting job to freshman Harris, who at best averaged around 4-5 ppg all season. But after Coates went down, Cuevas-Moore became a strong defensive companion with Harris, and had some good scoring games. They (Cuevas-Moore and Harris) added enough to Wilson, Davis, Gray to help take the team all the way.
So this season, what we have is a slightly less starting 5 from the 2017 team, but it's a much more better balanced starting 5 with Harris and Cooke being just as dominant a pair of offensive sources as anyone else on the team. And we still have Boston and Herbert-Harrigan who also are very strong offensive players, and Beal is providing enough of everything to be more of a contributor than hole on the floor.
BUT THEN, what completes the whole thing, is our bench is as talented and productive of any bench Dawn Staley ever had, minus 2014-15, when both Wilson and Coates came off the bench to be the team's 2nd and 3rd-leading scorers, rebounders, and shot-blockers.
It's this great balance of consistent contribution from BOTH the starters AND reserves that's making this team so strong. It's the best OVERALL team that Coach Staley has had at USC. Whether they match the 2016-2017 version's results, we'll have to wait and see......